Frit-Happens !

Fusing and Stained Glass Tips and FAQ's => Fusing Tips and FAQ's => Slumping => Topic started by: sandmor1 on May 04, 2014, 08:22:08 AM

Title: slumping into a candle holder
Post by: sandmor1 on May 04, 2014, 08:22:08 AM
Hello
I have just bought a square dish shaped candle holder. The glass slumped into the dish shape fine but didn't drop down into the round candle holder centre. (I hope you can understand that)    (Bullseye Glass...2 layers...18cm square)

The schedule I used was
150    600   10min
56      620   30min
9999   516   45min
66      400    0
off

I have used this schedule to slump several plates and dishes in my Skutt Hotstart but clearly it isn't right for the candle dish.
Could anyone offer me a better schedule, please.

Thank you

Sandra
Title: Re: slumping into a candle holder
Post by: Zeldazog on May 04, 2014, 12:47:56 PM
To be honest, finding the right schedule, for fusing and probably even more so for slumping is about getting to know your own kiln.  Every kiln is slightly different, even two of the same model will fire slightly differently.

So, experimenting is the key - nobody can really give you an exact firing schedule to suit your mould, your kiln, and one can learn a lot by trial and error - but I think you probably already know that you need to fire hotter.

Take a look on the Warm Glass site - there's loads of tip sheets under technical support, or Creative Ceramics who make a lot of slumping moulds.  They both have guidelines for slumping which will vary a lot depending on size and shape of the mould,etc - but you find they offer a good point to start exploring from.


Title: Re: slumping into a candle holder
Post by: Glassy Lou on May 04, 2014, 03:17:47 PM
Dawn's right. There's no "one schedule fits all" so you'll need to do a bit of experimenting.
I can tell you though that I had to go up to about 700 in my sc2 to get my candle plate to slump fully.
Good luck :)
Title: Re: slumping into a candle holder
Post by: June on May 04, 2014, 03:43:13 PM
I recommend you get the book Contemporary Warm Glass by Brad Walker, which is packed with information and I like The Joy Of Fusing, both of which are on offer at Tempsford Glass. The latter has quite a lot of suggested schedules and both explain how the schedules are made up so you can tweak to suit. We've never been on a course so it really is trial and error!  :)
Title: Re: slumping into a candle holder
Post by: sandmor1 on May 04, 2014, 05:55:54 PM
Thank you for all that. I do have the Brad Walker book but not the Joy of Fusing...I think I will get that next.

As I'm a real novice at this, I do have problems with fusing schedules, among other things.  (yes, I know you can tell by the questions I keep asking)

But I will get there...eventually...in the end....It is a very interesting and rewarding hobby, though a little on the expensive side. But what the heck..I don't smoke and my alcohol levels are low, though all that might change as might the amount of hair before get my fusing schedules sorted out. ;D

Sandra
Title: Re: slumping into a candle holder
Post by: ajda on May 04, 2014, 06:42:07 PM
If you've slumped successfully with that schedule already and this one nearly got there, maybe just try same again but raise your top temperature by 10-20 degrees and/or the soak time by 10-20 mins. I do quite a bit with recycled glass and every batch or bottle is different, so I sometimes fire the same piece several times over. Bullseye glass is quite expensive, but you might be surprised at how little your kiln costs on a firing cycle.
Title: Re: slumping into a candle holder
Post by: sandmor1 on May 04, 2014, 10:38:45 PM
how little your kiln costs on a firing cycle........

That is interesting, I have only had my kiln about 7 weeks so the 1st electric bill since getting it has yet to arrive. 

I have been kind of expecting a very much larger bill...maybe I will get a pleasant surprise.

Sandra
Title: Re: slumping into a candle holder
Post by: Zeldazog on May 04, 2014, 11:08:10 PM
Quote from: sandmor1 on May 04, 2014, 10:38:45 PM
how little your kiln costs on a firing cycle........

That is interesting, I have only had my kiln about 7 weeks so the 1st electric bill since getting it has yet to arrive. 

I have been kind of expecting a very much larger bill...maybe I will get a pleasant surprise.

Sandra

They used to quote that the Hotstart Pro used 50 pence per firing when I bought mine, which was about seven years ago -  I monitored it one firing at it used 4.5 kilowatts - my bigger Hobbyfuser used around 8Kw in a single firing, still under a quid.

They're very well insulated and hold their heat, far better than your average oven.  The plug in ones are only about 1.8Kw - your kettle is usually 3Kw and other heated items can be anywhere in that range.

A kiln is only heating at full power for a very short length of time during the firing cycle.  That slow ramp in segment one?  Listen to your kiln, it will hum when it's powering the elements - during a slow climb, you will hear them clicking on and off on regular basis.  It's only running at something like 20% power during this part of the cycle.  It will only ever be using it's full power if you have a fast rate of climb which probably breaks down to something like half an hour out of that whole cycle.  It barely uses anything during a controlled cool down.

A lot of people have the misconception that big kilns are expensive to run, but firebrick is such an efficient insulator that it really doesn't take all the kilns power to get the temperature you need.   Warm Glass give an approximate firing cost on some of the kilns they sell.

Title: Re: slumping into a candle holder
Post by: chas on May 05, 2014, 05:09:39 PM
Quote from: Zeldazog on May 04, 2014, 11:08:10 PM





They're very well insulated and hold their heat, far better than your average oven.



I just read that after remarking how hot the room was while firing at the mo...  I was wondering if it's possible to improve the insulation to ours (Naberthem F110) to help keep heat in.
I can't see why not (assuming no fire risk) though its cooling programme may be affected as it would lose heat more slowly.

Does anyone have an opinion on that?

Back to the question: when we've had trouble 'bottoming out', as has been said it's been either top temperature/hold too low/short or the curved rim over which the glass drops is too sharp - a bigger radius helps. If your mould is shop-bought, that should have been taken care of. Our final schedule for a 20mm sharpish drop was up to 835deg held for 35 mins.
Good luck,

Chas
Title: Re: slumping into a candle holder
Post by: Zeldazog on May 05, 2014, 06:02:32 PM
Quote from: chas on May 05, 2014, 05:09:39 PM

Quote from: Zeldazog on May 04, 2014, 11:08:10 PM
They're very well insulated and hold their heat, far better than your average oven.

I just read that after remarking how hot the room was while firing at the mo...  I was wondering if it's possible to improve the insulation to ours (Naberthem F110) to help keep heat in.

Obviously they do give off some heat, which you will feel especially in an enclosed room (when I had my Hotstart Pro at home, my kitchen, which is normally quite cold got really rather cosy during the pre-christmas rush) but  Nabertherm build top quality kilns and Warm Glass quote the firing costs of the F110 at around £1 a firing - for the size and power rating of that kiln, that's extremely frugal, so I'd think it was very well insulated already.

Title: Re: slumping into a candle holder
Post by: sandmor1 on May 06, 2014, 07:29:12 AM
Thank you to everyone with your thoughts and advice on both the slumping of the candle holder and also the kiln running costs.

I have finally got around to refiring the candle holder this morning. (I had a busy w/e)

I have upped the top temp from 620 to 660 and the hold from 30mins to 50mins. It will be out at around 8pm.

I found all the comments on the kiln running costs very interesting. I got my kiln from Warm Glass and I know they are very good but when it comes to electrical products I tend to be skeptical about manufacturers/retailers claims on running costs.

I am probably being unfair now, as I know things have improved in recent years with regard to publicity claims on products.

Sandra

Title: Re: slumping into a candle holder
Post by: marklaird on May 06, 2014, 11:15:55 AM
Hi Sandra,
Just seen this and thought I would add my slumping schedule if it is any help to you.
I've got an SC2 (also from Warm Glass)
Ramp at 200 to 520°C, hold 25min
Ramp at 330 to 650°C, hold 20min
Ramp AFAP to 516°C, hold 50min
Ramp at 60 to 371°C, hold 0
Ramp at 100 to 40°C

This seems to work for me on a small 8cm trinket dish with a flat base.

Hope it is of some use.

Mark
Title: Re: slumping into a candle holder
Post by: Zeldazog on May 06, 2014, 03:06:24 PM
Quote from: sandmor1 on May 06, 2014, 07:29:12 AM
I found all the comments on the kiln running costs very interesting. I got my kiln from Warm Glass and I know they are very good but when it comes to electrical products I tend to be skeptical about manufacturers/retailers claims on running costs.

I am probably being unfair now, as I know things have improved in recent years with regard to publicity claims on products.

I put my Hotstart Pro through a plug in monitor and it registered around 4.7Kw for a full cycle.  Even at current electricity prices, probably average around 11p per Kw/H that is still less 53p per cycle - if anything Warm Glass are being overcautious as they quote approximately 75p per cycle.

Similarly they quote 90p per firing for the Hobby-fuser.  I haven't put that through a monitor as it has a facility to tell you how much power it used on a cycle - it was definitely under 9Kw for a full fuse firing, so again, their figure of 90p is about right.
Title: Re: slumping into a candle holder
Post by: sandmor1 on May 06, 2014, 07:40:45 PM
Right...second slump was a little better but still not enough.

Can I go even higher than 660 (top) ? Or should I hold for even longer than 50mins ?

Also, this would be the third slumping....would that be OK ?

Sandra
Title: Re: slumping into a candle holder
Post by: chas on May 07, 2014, 10:13:21 AM
Quote from: sandmor1 on May 06, 2014, 07:40:45 PM
Right...second slump was a little better but still not enough.

Can I go even higher than 660 (top) ? Or should I hold for even longer than 50mins ?

Also, this would be the third slumping....would that be OK ?

Sandra

Well the robust answer to all three questions is 'yes', but not necessarily together. Part of the problem solving process is to identify the stumbling-block, and too many changes at once may not do that. You'll want to repeat the firing - successfully - on other occasions...

With due respect to your initial creation, you may (may) have to regard this one as sacrificial in the cause of experience, so, I'd whack up the temperature first (50 mins hold is quite long already) take a chance and bake it again!

Or, if you'd really like to preserve this one, you could just cut a plain piece of glass and fire that in the mould to the new experimental schedule.

Chas
Title: Re: slumping into a candle holder
Post by: ajda on May 07, 2014, 12:18:57 PM
Good advice from Chas - if  you want a result that you are happy with and confident you can repeat in future, be prepared to sacrifice the odd piece in the course of experimenting. Some glass doesn't like being re-fired too many times - it may start devitrifying, for example - but I think most Bullseye should be good for multiple slump firings. I've been playing with their Opaline Striker - the more you cook that, the more milky and opaque it becomes, a change which is non-reversible - I've messed up quite a few nice pieces trying to get it just right. Even if you seriously overcook a piece and end up with nothing but a warped puddle you'll have learned something in the process! Another bit of good advice would be to keep detailed notes on every firing...
Title: Re: slumping into a candle holder
Post by: sandmor1 on May 08, 2014, 08:10:18 AM
Hi Chas, thanks for the advice.

I slumped the piece again, going up another 20degs and once again it was slightly improved but not what I was hoping for.

The candle holder part of the dish has straight sides about 3/8" deep with a 3" diameter base but the piece just curves down to a flat bottom about 1" across without touching the straight sides. Maybe I have got this wrong...should it follow the exact shape of the mould or just a droop?

Actually it is quite nice as it is and I am going to give it to my daughter in law for her birthday next week but I am going to try another one maybe going up another 10/20 degs. But if I still just get the same droop rather an definate drop on the sides then I can live with that.

Sandra
Title: Re: slumping into a candle holder
Post by: chas on May 08, 2014, 12:02:47 PM
Sandra, at the point where the top drops into the holder, is the transition 'over the edge' sharp or rounded?

There is no reason I can think of why you shouldn't get a better representation of the mould shape - other than the experience I had with a similar mould.

In my case it was made from Kaiserlee board and as well as increasing top temperature and hold I was able to round the edges to promote an easier slump. Most likely you won't want to modify the mould at first - but do try upping the top temp again and experiment with a piece of new glass. You may need to be well into the 750+. The other, slim possibility is that in slumping it is trapping air. If the mould is well designed and proven, it shouldn't be a problem - but  there's often air holes: have you blocked them with kilnwash?

To give you some idea of the variables that may apply, here's some info from our experience:

Warmglass basic schedule for Bullseye: 4 hours up to 673deg hold for 10 mins

Our general approach for float: add 15 - 20deg

Our final schedule to get a flat bottomed drop  in the project mentioned: 4 hours up to 835deg hold for 35 mins.

As said before, nothing intuitive, all from experimentation and note taking, all kilns are different, but see how different it can be in the same kiln but with different moulds.

Good luck,

Chas
Title: Re: slumping into a candle holder
Post by: sandmor1 on May 08, 2014, 12:25:29 PM
Quote from: chas on May 08, 2014, 12:02:47 PM
Sandra, at the point where the top drops into the holder, is the transition 'over the edge' sharp or rounded?

There is no reason I can think of why you shouldn't get a better representation of the mould shape - other than the experience I had with a similar mould.

Our general approach for float: add 15 - 20deg

Our final schedule to get a flat bottomed drop  in the project mentioned: 4 hours up to 835deg hold for 35 mins.

As said before, nothing intuitive, all from experimentation and note taking, all kilns are different, but see how different it can be in the same kiln but with different moulds.

Good luck,

Chas

Chas, it is rounded, definately not sharp which is what I had in mind.

I will try again in a few days when I have finished firing the other pieces I have ready for the kiln. ...

I do love this hobby but my little Hotstart is just not big enough...I will have to increase my "donations" to the lottery  ;D

Sandra

Title: Re: slumping into a candle holder
Post by: Moira HFG on May 08, 2014, 01:37:55 PM
Sorry if this is obvious.....have you checked the air holes in the bottom of the mould aren't blocked with batt wash? If the air in the bottom of the mould can't escape, it might stop the glass from slumping into place properly.
Title: Re: slumping into a candle holder
Post by: sandmor1 on May 09, 2014, 09:17:58 AM
Quote from: Moira HFG on May 08, 2014, 01:37:55 PM
Sorry if this is obvious.....have you checked the air holes in the bottom of the mould aren't blocked with batt wash? If the air in the bottom of the mould can't escape, it might stop the glass from slumping into place properly.

Thanks Moira, but No, the holes are clear as a bell....
Title: Re: slumping into a candle holder
Post by: Warm Glass UK on May 09, 2014, 09:34:21 AM
Please pick up the phone and call our Technical staff for advice on this if you need to (01934 863344) - we offer free technical advice and support on any kiln that we sell for as long as you need it (and some need it for a long time I can assure you which is totally fine by us). It's really important to us that if a customer has invested (alot of money) in a kiln, then they get to be comfortable with it and understand how to get the results they want. The best people to speak to are either Simon or Megan for Technical advice.
Title: Re: slumping into a candle holder
Post by: sandmor1 on May 10, 2014, 07:30:23 AM
Quote from: Warm Glass UK on May 09, 2014, 09:34:21 AM
Please pick up the phone and call our Technical staff for advice on this if you need to (01934 863344) - we offer free technical advice and support on any kiln that we sell for as long as you need it (and some need it for a long time I can assure you which is totally fine by us). It's really important to us that if a customer has invested (alot of money) in a kiln, then they get to be comfortable with it and understand how to get the results they want. The best people to speak to are either Simon or Megan for Technical advice.


That is kind of you, Thank you.

I am going to have another go next week but if that fails to achieve what I am looking for I will call.

Sandra